Decision Maker Blog — For Georgia Education Leaders From Recognizing Words to Owning Them
Last week’s Applied Learning Network post introduced the Acrostic Vocabulary strategy — a concept acquisition tool that moves learners beyond copying definitions into building their own understanding of a concept from the inside out. Week 7 moves the vocabulary work one level higher.
The Analogy strategy asks learners not just to understand a word but to explain how it relates to another word — and why that relationship holds for a second pair of words in exactly the same way. That is a test of higher-order thought. It is the difference between knowing words and owning them.
Teachers assign a complete analogy. No guessing at the right answer. Learners explain it in three moves: how the first pair relates, how the second pair relates, and how both pairs relate in the same way. That third move is where vocabulary understanding is shallow or deep.
What You Observe
The analogy prompt is on the board alongside the key terms of the lesson — the words learners will need to use but may not recall on the spot or know how to spell. The teacher model is visible: all three moves completed, relationship type named, key terms used throughout. Learners are writing, pencil in hand, PALs beside them, working through 14–18 minutes of application.
PAL-pairs are negotiating. When two learners see the relationships differently — when one argues cause-and-effect and the other argues consumer-to-consumed or problem-solution — the session reaches an increased Depth of Knowledge. Learners thinking critically and boldly. These are moments to celebrate, and they are the moments worth noting on a walkthrough. Learners have alerted their teachers to relationships the teachers themselves had not anticipated. That is the strategy working at its highest level.
What the Disagreements Tell You
Quick agreement on Move 3 often means both learners have named the relationship type without fully explaining why. A PAL who pushes back — “Is that really cause-and-effect, or is it something else?” — is doing the work the strategy was designed to produce.
That accountable conversation does not happen by accident. It happens because the self-assessment rubric gives learners a specific question to answer and the PAL a specific role to play. The structure creates the accountability.
What the Self-Assessment Tells You
Before the PAL exchange, learners assess their own writing against three questions: Did I use key terms with meaning? Did I write meaningful sentences and facts? Does my writing show evidence from the lesson or text? Each question earns an exceed, meet, or approach. The PAL checks each rating against the evidence in the writing itself and signs.
That sequence — three-move explanation, self-assessment, peer accountability — is the full 60%+. No red pen has been lifted. The teacher already knows, from monitoring the PAL exchange, which learners named the relationship type with precision and which learners are still restating the analogy sentence.
The Walkthrough Question
One question anchors any Analogy observation: Can learners name the relationship type and explain why it holds for both pairs? If yes — the strategy is working at the level it was designed for. If learners can complete Moves 1 and 2 but stall at Move 3 — the teacher model may need to make the relationship-naming step more explicit next time.
That is the professional conversation the strategy makes possible. Precise, observable, and pointed at the next instructional step.
Applied Learning Network | First Flight Applied Literacy Program | writingtowin.com
Contact: Dr. Warren Combs, drcombs@writingtowin.com, office@writingtowin.com, 706-521-2530

1 Comment