Extended reading to extended writing. That’s real balance.
Honest Balanced Literacy #3: Write as They Read, Read as They Write
From the last two blogs, we know students benefit from systematic practice as they read or participate in a class lesson.
#7 – When they practice creating the grammatical patterns they study to the point of automaticity, they naturally use the patterns in their speaking and writing. (Achieving language fluency, sentence-by-sentence)
#8 – When they use the course vocabulary to explain what they know about a given lesson on a given day, they retain the vocabulary longer. (Achieving language fluency, short reading by short writing)
How about keeping reading and writing together with longer reading passages and written essays? Since Reading First in 2002 and Writing Next in 2007, they continue to remain separate.
I knew there had to be a way that systematic writing can propel students through differentiated reading comprehension levels – literal, inferential, evaluative, and applied reading.
And conversely, there had to be a way that systematic reading can propel students through the writing process in responding to paired texts – prewriting, drafting, revising, and self-and peer-assessment of final drafts.
In 2015, I undertook the task. Far too many schools reported that teachers followed adopted reading programs that focused first on strategies of reading comprehension with less-strategic writing tasks to follow. And in the classroom, teachers spend almost all instruction time on reading strategies, often choosing writing to be a more free response or omitting it completely.
My only recourse was to create the reading passages internally. An author team wrote them, keeping them at the upper level of the Lexile band for each grade level. They were at least as complex as students met on end-of-year tests. Given this fact, we set PALS (peer-assisted learning system) as the default student work group. Together they moved through scripted tasks at four levels of differentiated reading comprehension. Each session was a variation on the jigsaw strategy where students met in small groups and became experts as they wrote out their reports. They then report back to their base group or the whole class to write out the reports in their own words. Students were supported through all of these steps in a single 32-page green packet with ample room for all of their reading tasks and independent writing tasks.
In reading comprehension, students are writing as much as they read.
From here, it is simpler to make sure students are reading as much as they write as they create a multi-paragraph response to reading texts. The texts remain in view as PALS create their prewriting plans and then write their first drafts separately. Of course, the key terms from the text are listed alphabetically for students to use as they write. After the first drafts are complete, PALS read their drafts aloud to each other before they help each other create a plan for revision that includes concrete references to the reading texts.
The reaction of students to writing as they read and re-reading as they wrote was immediate. Emails from teachers reported student comments like
We’re getting another green packet, right?
Do we get to keep our packets? I want to show mom.
What more is there to add?
Contact: Dr. Warren Combs, drcombs@writingtowin.com, 706-521-2530, office@writingtowin.com, www.writingtowin.com

No Comments