new header JUN19 jpg

For Administrators – Sentence Combining – The Subliminal Grammar Lesson

Here is a principle that Applied Learning Network will keep naming until it becomes the organizing idea of every professional learning session in the country: application is the most important part of learning—not identifying the concept, not learning the procedure, but actually doing the thing until it becomes automatic.

Identify the concept (10% of instructional energy). Learn the procedure (30%). Apply it, practice it, live it, own it (60%).

Most grammar instruction in American classrooms inverts that ratio. Learners spend the bulk of their time identifying parts of speech and learning the rules—with little or no practice actually creating the patterns in their own writing. Sentence combining, done right, refuses to work that way.

 

What 80 Studies Over 60 Years Already Know

The short version of a very large finding: since 1965, more than 80 experimental studies—conducted across 12 or more countries, spanning six decades, covering every major student subgroup—have demonstrated that systematic sentence-combining practice improves student writing. Not just in one grade. Not just for strong learners. For all of them—like a rising tide raising all ships. It significantly improves reading comprehension and academic vocabulary as well.

Steve Graham and Dolores Perin named sentence combining as one of only 11 writing strategies with effect sizes strong enough for confident recommendation in their landmark 2007 Carnegie report, Writing Next. Eleven strategies—out of every approach ever studied—and sentence combining made the cut.

The reason it works is exactly what the 10/30/60 principle predicts. Sentence combining is an application strategy at its core. Learners don’t identify clause types on a worksheet. They take language presented in parts and create it—out loud, by hand, with a partner or small group—until the structures feel natural. That is the 60%.

 

What “Done Right” Actually Looks Like in a Classroom

A teacher presents a combining puzzle laid out like a math addition problem—short, simple sentences stacked on top of each other, with a signal word printed to the right.

Base sentence     The dog got wet. (Since)

Signal sentence   The dog came inside. (,)

Learners know that signal words move in front of the simple sentence they follow—and that repeated words are deleted or replaced with a pronoun. The combined sentence becomes:

Since the dog got wet, it came inside.

The combining begins orally. Learners practice the target grammatical pattern 4-5 times out loud in whole-class or small-group exchange before a single word is written. This is not warm-up. It is the instructional core.

Then they write—offline, with pencil and paper. Nueller and Oppenheimer’s research on handwriting versus keyboarding confirms what experienced teachers already sense: the physical act of forming the sentence by hand creates stronger encoding of the structure than typing it on a screen. This step is non-negotiable.

Then comes the choral close. The class stands—like a choir—and combines one puzzle after another without hesitation. One voice, made from thirty. This is the moment the grammatical structures move from know to felt. Learners who cannot yet hear a complex sentence on their own borrow the fluency of the group until they can. The 15-second celebration that follows is not a filler. It is the affective anchor that makes learners want to come back tomorrow and do it again.

No one is told to use this pattern in independent writing. That instruction is deliberately, intentionally withheld. The reason is Cognitive Load Theory. The brain cannot simultaneously manage what I want to say and a grammatical constraint I was assigned. So you don’t assign it. You practice it, celebrate it, and move on. Then you wait and watch and read.

Within weeks, learners start reaching for those structures when they need them—not because a rubric told them to, but because the structure is now in their repertoire. Automatic. Available. Theirs.

 

The Monday Morning Version—What This Costs a School

This is a 25-minute daily practice, not an add-on program.

8 minutes — Oral-kinesthetic minilesson on the target grammatical pattern, using                                      small-group interaction

12 minutes — PAL-pair coaching through written practice of the same pattern

5 minutes — Whole-group choral close, followed by a 15-second energetic celebration

No technology required. No consumables beyond a pencil and a page. No prep beyond the teacher guide.

The Simple, Powerful Rewrite Passage produces a short writing sample before and after the instructional cycle. It documents growth in words per sentence, clause complexity, and syntactic maturity—numbers a teacher can show a principal, numbers that move as learners grow as writers.

Applied Grammar is not a grammar program. It is a daily application strategy that builds the grammatical fluency every student needs in reading, in writing, and in every academic task that requires navigating a complex idea in complex language. That is the 60%. That is the whole point.

 

Next week: How educators in New Jersey have used existing reading passages to focus the application of writing skills, specifically revision.

Applied Learning Network | First Flight Applied Literacy Program | writingtowin.com

Contact information – Dr. Warren Combs, drcombs@writingtowin.com, office@writingtowin.com, 706-521-2530

 

No Comments

Leave a Reply